Rumors are that Wenger’s offsides rule will go into effect in the next year. The rule is basically that the offsides line will now be dependent on the last body part being in line with a defender rather than the first body part being past the defender. I personally think this will result in teams parking the bus so that they limit the speed aspect of the forwards. It will be so much more difficult to pull and offsides trap with this rule set. I also think VAR will butcher this for the next few seasons.

So anyways, what rule would you implement or remove if you had the options to? I have two:

Throws-ins: don’t require one foot to be on the ground or the ball to go cleanly behind the head. Two hands on the ball and throw it in, however. you want, that’s it. Granny style? Go for it.

PK’s: Have the players line up ten yards behind the 18 and once the whistle is blown they can go after the ball. This would illuminate the weird runs up to the ball or the final jump kick, which is almost a cheat code against goalies. I’m a united fan so this would of course impact Bruno but I think think it makes sense. The attacker still has the advantage being that it’s a PK but also adds a bit of extra pressure. Shootouts would be so much more involved.

What rule changes can you think of?

  • keepontrying111@alien.topB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    10 months ago

    offside should be just like hockey its all about the feet as long as your feet are equal or behind the feet of the defender you’re on side. its worked in hockey for 100 years.

    the Wenger rule has one stupid part what you’ll see is a ton of attackers grabbing the shirt of the defender to stay onside. So instead of 100 var onsides checks we will have the grab check.

    as to throw ins,. why would you change it, that’s just stupid, might as well change so you can use your hands in the game too. or remove the ball and replace it with a cube. its not like throw ins were changed to be what they are now they’ve been that way for over 50 years.

    • JOKU1990@alien.topOPB
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      10 months ago

      Regarding throw ins, I just feel like the rules around them are silly and they are sometimes loosely enforced. I remember when Darmian came to united he got busted for lifting his foot off the ground a few times. The commentators were saying how in Italy the rules around throws ins aren’t really enforced.

      By eliminating those rules we would see a couple things:

      • no more turnovers from a bad throw in
      • more throw ins into the box leading to more goals
    • JOKU1990@alien.topOPB
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      10 months ago

      Regarding throw ins, I just feel like the rules around them are silly and they are sometimes loosely enforced. I remember when Darmian came to united he got busted for lifting his foot off the ground a few times. The commentators were saying how in Italy the rules around throws ins aren’t really enforced.

      By eliminating those rules we would see a couple things:

      • no more turnovers from a bad throw in
      • more throw ins into the box leading to more goals