The problem is that AI is not useless. It has a lot of other issues, but not that it is never a helpful tool.
With constrained data sets it’s actually really useful.
Parsing text and logs and correlating events, super useful.
When you dump all human “intelligence” into it you discover how dumb we are collectively.
It’s great to explore a new codebase for example.
AI is fine when it is your hands. Not when it is your brain. As long as you can vet it it can be useful for coding. Its the moment we give agency away to the AI that many see issues with it.
From the project’s README:
Also note that the python visualizer tool has been basically written by vibe-coding. I know more about analog filters – and that’s not saying much – than I do about python. It started out as my typical “google and do the monkey-see-monkey-do” kind of programming, but then I cut out the middle-man – me – and just used Google Antigravity to do the audio sample visualizer.
This is the commit: https://github.com/torvalds/AudioNoise/commit/93a72563cba609a414297b558cb46ddd3ce9d6b5
Tbf it’s his project so he can do whatever he wants
Issue is when people do things like that one dude who had Claude implement support for DWARF in… Whatever language it was (Something MLy I think?) and literally didn’t even remove the copyright attribution to some random 3rd person that Claude added. It was a PR of several thousand lines, all AI generated and he had no idea how it worked, but said it’s ok, Claude understands it. He didn’t even tell anyone he was going to be working on it so there was no discussion of the architecture beforehand.
Edit: Ocaml. So I was right that it was something MLy lol
Claude understands it
Only the words of it tho.
Only the probability of the next token after tokenisation of it.
Not even that.
Quick, let’s all abandon Linux (edit: and git) because the main developer did something we don’t like! /s
I would say hans reiser enters the room… But he didn’t…
Just in case it slipped your eyes when you saw “Torvalds”: this is not about the Linux kernel.
AI can be a useful tool.
Looks like he’s just toying around with it in some project. Why would he take other’s words for it when he can just test it himself? Try it out, see what happens, draw conclusions.
There’s a lot of mindless hype and a lot of mindless hate around these tools. Makes sense to try these tools and form your own opinion
Didn’t he daily a M series macbook when they came out?
I don’t remember people being obnoxious about that
“AI is useless because I want it to be so” is jedi logic, not applicable irl
This whole thing feels like a celebrity ad.
I’ve long found it funny how some people claim that generative AI produces terrible slop, and simultaneously that it’s a huge threat to their jobs.
The people who make firing decisions often aren’t the ones doing the day-to-day work.
It’s very possible to be replaced by a machine that does a worse job, as long as your (ex-) boss isn’t aware of it.
Or sometimes they are aware, but it’s enough cheaper that they don’t care.
Or sometimes its a job they legally need to have but where they really don’t want quality work (e.g. support).
Schrodinger’s
immigrantAi
deleted by creator
Nothing, probably. The whole thing is a fun side project for messing around with audio processing, and he decided to outsource the visualisation part (not even the logic, just the visualisation) because he knows jack shit about python and learning it for just one cosmetic part of the project doesn’t make much sense.
These are – like the analog circuits that started my journey – toy effects that you shouldn’t take seriously. The main design goal has been to learn about digital audio processing basics. Exactly like the guitar pedal was about learning about the hardware side.
Also note that the python visualizer tool has been basically written by vibe-coding. I know more about analog filters – and that’s not saying much – than I do about python. It started out as my typical “google and do the monkey-see-monkey-do” kind of programming, but then I cut out the middle-man – me – and just used Google Antigravity to do the audio sample visualizer.
So this isn’t some paid ad for Google, it’s a busy man pursuing a hobby to learn something and taking a shortcut for a part of the hobby he’s not interested in.
