The sub popped up in my feed a few months ago and all I really see here is people complaining (mainly about City, Newcastle, UAE, Saudi Arabia, and refs) and posting about conspiracies and conspiracy theories.

There’s very little in the way of moderate football discussion, and it feels like a circlejerk at times.

Has it always been this way? R/soccer has had its own challenges for a long time, but even there the proportion of interesting content tends to be higher.

I enjoy participating in subs like r/championship and r/theother14

  • PJBuzz@alien.topBEnglish
    1·
    10 months ago

    There are no Reddit subs available for intelligent football conversation between rival fans.

    The only thing that exists is a dog-pile competitions, and club specific subs where you can talk to fellow supporters. If anything, the dog-piling was not as bad here than r/soccer, but these days it’s barely distinguishable.

    Occasionally there is a pocket of decent conversation within a thread, but its rare, and one fan base or another will take issue with it and start derailing it with prejudice.

    • kwhicks@alien.topBEnglish
      1·
      10 months ago

      And reading words v discussion in person is very hard to pick up on certain queues

      • PJBuzz@alien.topBEnglish
        1·
        10 months ago

        Sure, but that wouldn’t account for the level of tribalism on Reddit.

        It’s just full of cunts, and the content of someone’s message is way, way, way down the list of reasons people will engage and “vote” on it.

        At this point it’s almost worthless having an NUFC flair, or even using this account to post on r/soccer or r/premierleague. Typically doesn’t matter what I say, it almost immediately it gets pummels with downvotes within seconds.

        This is one of the rare occations that I’ve somehow slipped through (for now). I would say the totally scientific ratio is 1/10 posts that happens.

    • W26D12L0@alien.topBEnglish
      1·
      10 months ago

      Exactly my sentiments, I have my mates that I see once a week or once a fortnight or so and there’s never any animosity in our discussions and I genuinely learn things from considering other angles

      On here I don’t know what it is but people seem different online it’s very strange

      I will say there was a point this sub was more bearable but it isn’t any more for anything other than having a laugh, although that’s getting harder to do, people are so sensitive

    • prkr88@alien.topBEnglish
      1·
      10 months ago

      I also got banned from r/soccer for a nothing comment.

      Echo Chambers

    • TexehCtpaxa@alien.topBEnglish
      1·
      10 months ago

      Tbf even the big media organizations dedicated to talking about football for entertainment are equally bad.

      I miss the days of talkSport where Peterborough and Northampton Town fans would call in moaning or talking up their side or moaning about how bad their lower league footy was that day. Since moving to the states I get way better epl coverage but also miss the soccer Saturday where I’d see updates from “rubbish” teams bc they still mattered.

      But overall, idk the last time I heard anyone have an intelligent convo about footy. Sometimes there’s good analysis, but it’s something objective.