• 0 Posts
  • 5 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: October 2nd, 2023

help-circle
  • Yes.

    The entire premise “if only the on field decisions were more correct then people would enjoy football more” is completely flawed.

    Maybe, at best, people would complain less, but it doesn’t mean they will watch more or importantly spend more money attending or watching on TV.

    Additionally, what has been completely highlighted is there is a huge amount of referring decisions that nobody can agree on what the right answer is.

    I gave up on the NFL because of how awful replay made it to watch. It became a game within the game. It became a competition ABOUT the rules instead of under the rules.




  • Here’s the fundamental flaw with VAR. even when things are studied in super zoom and super slow motion people still can’t come to a consensus on the right call. There’s no fixing that. What one person considers reckless or dangerous, another person may not. Even in binary situations like out of bounds or offside there are plenty of examples of situations where we can’t definitively know.

    The thing var is based on, “correct” calls, just doesn’t exist.

    Sure, there are a handful of times, wrong players getting red cards, missed ear bitings etc that VAR maybe could fix. But a vast majority var just makes worse.

    Var has got to go. I don’t watch football because they precisely apply unambiguous rules. That’s chess or darts or snooker.