• 0 Posts
  • 6 Comments
Joined 11 months ago
cake
Cake day: October 19th, 2023

help-circle



  • Agreed, and the entire idea that stripping City’s titles = giving them retroactively to the 2nd place finisher is dumb. Remove City from the equation in a particular season and everything about a season changes. 2nd place didn’t win the title, and there’s no guarantee that they would have if City hadn’t existed in the PL. Whole season just gets an asterisk if it’s up to me, nobody gets credited with the win.

    Same deal for example in baseball for the 2017 Astros win, in no scenario whatsoever should the Dodgers be awarded the World Series trophy, even if the title had been stripped from the Astros. 2017 just doesn’t have a World Series winner in that case, with the note being one of the teams cheated. But the Dodgers didn’t “win” the trophy, and it’s impossible to know if they would have if Houston hadn’t cheated.