Wyoming’s “Stand Your Ground” law says you don’t have to run from a confrontation before defending yourself. That is what Rihanna Kelver and her counsel are asking a Laramie judge to consider as they seek protection from prosecution in a felony case stemming from a confrontation outside the Crowbar.
This whole thing sounds stupid to me because they’re arguing over whether deadly force was warranted or not. She never actually shot the guy so there was no deadly force! The tl;dr version is:
- Guy yelled some slurs.
- Woman crosses the street to talk to the guy.
- Guy shoves her to the ground.
- While on ground she draws and readies her pistol.
- The guy walks away. No shot is fired.
The guy physically assaulted her. Sure we can argue if a shove with no weapons is enough to warrant being shot to death, but that’s not what happened so who cares. Sounds like she did absolutely nothing wrong unless she wasn’t allowed to have the gun or something.
But she’s not being charged with use of deadly force. She’s being charged with aggravated assault, which is threatening the use of deadly force, i.e. brandishing.
The stand your ground defense might not hold up because she approached him, then drew the gun after he pushed her. He wasn’t a threat until she put herself in a situation where he could be.
I’m sure a jury would return not guilty, but she didn’t do her defense any favors. If someone is shouting insults from a distance, you should walk away or at least not approach. If they follow you, then brandishing is more justified.
Ah I missed that detail, thanks for the clarification. I disagree about the approaching part, anyone can approach anyone in public. Approaching isn’t an aggressive action, especially not like pushing someone is. He said words, she got closer and said words, he got physical, she almost got physical back. I hope she beats the rap.
Witnesses say she had her hand at her hip like she was ready to draw a weapon as she approached. She also drew as they were leaving (the push was pushing her out of the way).
And while approaching someone isn’t inherently an aggressive action, insulting someone is. Approaching a stranger who is insulting you is escalating things by confronting them.
She also didn’t do herself any favors by claiming she pulled a non-existent knife.
But let’s swap the genders here, like someone else in the thread said. If a group of black women started calling a white guy a racist, then he went out of his way to confront them about it and got shoved, would we be cool with him pulling a gun? Would we be saying he was just standing his ground?
I didn’t see anything saying that she had her hand on her hip ready to draw, but even if true, so what.
I don’t live in a state with these kind of gun laws, but in her state them’s the rules. Personally I think getting physical with someone in any way is a big escalation, it’s literally a use of force. Force should be reasonably appropriate and somewhat equal, i.e. you don’t get to shoot someone for bumping into you at the store (or shoot someone who is not or is no longer a threat, possibly like this situation). You might say the guy had no weapons and simply pushed her, but the fact remains that she returned his force with none. It could have been the case that she got pushed over and then the guy goes to kick or stomp her in which case I think shooting is appropriate. I think the brandishing charge is probably bullshit, because it doesn’t seem like she was waving around the gun to intimidate or threaten someone. It sounds like she took out the gun to use it during a physical altercation and then didn’t when she realized it was not necessary.
No need to swap genders or substitute ideologically different people, I’m cool with a legally-carried gun being pulled during a defensive physical fight every time. You said that insulting someone is an inherently aggressive action, and sure I’ll mostly agree, but the big difference is that it’s legal. Insults are fist amendment protected speech most of the time, pushing someone is battery.
I think getting physical with someone in any way is a big escalation,
And it appears that Wyoming considers approaching someone who has had words with you is an escalation.
the fact remains that she returned his force with none.
Brandishing a weapon is… I don’t konw if it’s a use of force or some other classification, but there are laws against that.
It sounds to me that the court will consider all the arguments and come to whatever conclusion the law specifies. Or maybe it won’t and the law should be changed, or… dunno. Just responding to two minor things you said that I thought required minor replies. :)
Yeah it’s all good man, I appreciate the banter. Now I wish there was an easy way to follow up on this and find out the conclusion.
Yeah, that’s the main problem with this stuff (lemmy/reddit/etc).
The Freedom Fuel thing just popped up again, for example, and until it did I’d forgotten about it. We know more about it now, and if it hadn’t popped up again, I’d’ve never thought about it again. heh.
Except, from the description above, the use of slurs in public has long been held to be “Fighting Words” under 1st amendment law. His initial actions were not protected speech and are considered an act of violence.
Also, her walking over to confront him was not an invitation for assault. He provoked her, assaulted her, and she threatened to defend herself if he continued his assault. This is how these sorts of cases have been adjudicated for a long time. We will see if this one is, but it is how it should be.
Kinda. Fighting words have been so narrowed as to be functionally meaningless. Cohen v Californa (I think?) basically said “emotions alone aren’t enough.”
Practically, fighting words have to rise to the level of being reasonably interpreted as an imminent threat to get outside of First Amendment protection.
In this case, sounds like the assholes yelled their slurs and kept moving, so that wouldn’t justify the use of force.
If an insult is a violent act, then confrontation is escalating things. She wasn’t in danger when they were just being assholes from the other side of the street.
deleted by creator
That’s why you don’t engage.
You can’t shoot someone because they pushed you after you came up to them.
The stand your ground defense might not hold up because she approached him, then drew the gun after he pushed her. He wasn’t a threat until she put herself in a situation where he could be.
Yeah, this is a real good point. She is almost certainly going to be found at fault here. Heckling does not justify a reply with a threat of deadly force. She was not in fear of her life or grievous bodily harm, which is what you need to justify threats of deadly force.
Except the threat of deadly force was not in reply to the heckling, but the actual assault of him pushing her onto the ground. Assuming these were anti trans insults I fully understand being fearful for your life after that.
Battery*
In most jurisdictions assault is the threat of violence and battery is the actions.
But witnesses say she approached with her hand at her hip, as if ready to draw a gun. If true, that means she had already determined she was in danger by approaching.
In that case, assuming the guy who shoved her saw the hand position, it could be argued by the prosecutors that the push was in self defense. She was allegedly pushed out of the way as they were leaving, then pulled a gun.
She also lied and said she pulled a knife, which seriously danages the credibility of her version.
The law isn’t there to protect trans people that defend themselves.
Why? It seems the law is working as intended here.
They will find a reason to rule that actually she committed attempted murder. They don’t want trans people to be safe in public.
“to talk to the guy”.
She was clearly looking for a confrontation, and had a gun, and she intended to use it.
She had every opportunity to leave, but chose not to. Getting shoved is also not a good reason to shoot someone.
Just because you’re trans doesn’t mean you’re some saint who can do no wrong, you can be just as big an asshole as anyone else, I wish people would understand that because right now trans people get treated online like they’re always right, always beyond reproach, and always the victims, which is dumb af.
She wasn’t the one that started it. If someone talks shitty to you, you don’t have to just take it because you’re a minority.
Also, she didn’t shoot the guy.
More importantly, she didn’t even discharge the gun, even as a warning shot.
Hmm. I could see this going either way depending on the judge.
Kelver said she then crossed the intersection toward the man because she wanted to better understand what was happening.
This is going to be a problem for the defence. Someones aggressively yelling at you, and you close the distance putting yourself within reach and in harms way.
That’s not to say she should have been assaulted or that it’s ok in anyway; but that advance could be interpreted as aggravating the situation. Stand your ground means you’re not required to retreat, but it doesn’t mean you can/should advance into danger until you are actually harmed either.
I don’t think she should be charged, but I’m not too sure the court will agree.
Zimmerman stalked a kid before murdering him, after being told not to by authorities. Rittenhouse went looking for murder victims. Walking towards someone can’t be worse than that.
Rittenhouse was being confronted by people who just saw him murder someone and tried to stop him so he murdered more people and then ran home, past police, to a different state and he was found ‘innocent.’
Bear in mind he was really only “innocent” because he was 17. Generally you must legally be allowed to possess a gun in order to claim self defense. No matter how cut and dry a self defense claim is, if you are illegally carrying, it’s usually moot. Had he been 16, his possession would have been criminalized under one law, which would have killed his self defense claim. Had he been 18, there was a different law that would have made it illegal for him to carry. But Wisconsin fucked that up by leaving 17 for some un-fucking-explicable reason not defined.
Amazingly, being 17 also somehow made straw purchases not illegal.
Yeah but walking towards someone while trans? In Wyoming. The state where they killed Matt Sheppard.
Ahh yeah that’s right, trans panic is still a legal defense for murdering them
In the America’s Suicide Belt, pretty much
It’s not worse than that. She’s not being charged with a hate crime, civil rights violations, or homicide.
She’s being charged with brandishing, and her choice of actions don’t help her legal defense. Approaching a potential threat and then acting on it isn’t standing your ground.
Note that I’m not saying she should be charged for it, but she didn’t help her situation at all.
Yup.
I think the case comes down to: would she have crossed the street if she didn’t have a gun?
If she would have crossed the street without a gun, then legitimately not hearing what they said seems valid.
If she wouldn’t have crossed the street without a gun, kinda sounds like she wanted a reason to use it.
The same people who call Rittenhouse a hero apply a different standard here.
Those people are brainwashed and we expect them to have double standards. There IS some discussion to be had in this case amongst reasonable people.
When I first read about this, it was presented as:
Trans person existing outside bar Shoved to the ground Draws weapon, does not fire Trans person faces charges
The above situation definitely sounds like a “stand your ground” type of situation, and I thought it was ridiculous that she was charged.
Inserting “crossed the street to confront the person yelling slurs” (while admirable) could be understood by reasonable people to fall under “initiated the confrontation”.
I use the word confront, because that’s what I would be crossing the street to do. I don’t think I would be “trying to understand the situation”.
It’s interesting that you mentioned Rittenhouse because part of what makes him guilty in my mind is that he clearly went out if his way looking for trouble. This is my big issue with “stand your ground” vs “castle doctrine” in general. Did this person go out of their way looking for trouble? That’s what the judge has to decide.
I think she should be able to press charges for assault though, the guy shoved her to the ground, why shouldn’t he be charged too? He’s definitely not innocent in this situation especially since everyone agrees he started the while confrontation by yelling slurs.
Another thing that’s interesting about this to me is that IF the charges are thrown out under “stand your ground”, are we saying that she WOULD have been justified using deadly force here? I think if she had actually shot the guy we’d be having a different discussion.
That was my takeaway from the article as well. This is not a clear cut case for either side.
Honestly, it should be a wash. Everyone made bad decisions here, so give them differed adjudication with some community service and maybe mandatory therapy.
Sadly ironic this is in Laramie, Wyoming - the only reason I’ve heard of it is because of The Laramie Project, about the hate-crime-fuelled murder of Matthew Shepherd, a young gay man killed for his sexuality and subsequently celebrated by the Westboro Baptist Church.
The law protects me and binds you
I can’t find the actual video, but the descriptions I can find of the video will make it difficult to rely on self defense and stand your ground, per the language of the law in Wyoming.
She could be considered by a judge or jury the “initial aggressor” by approaching the three men, which negates stand your ground in WY. Or the guys could be considered the initial aggressors as they were yelling slurs at her. The video descriptions say she was walking toward them with her hand near her hip as if ready to pull a weapon, but the descriptions also say you can’t see where she was keeping the gun (it was found afterward in her bag… after she told the police she pulled a knife not a gun, and no knife was found).
The descriptions I’ve read (again, I haven’t found the video yet) say that the dude pushed her down and to the side as part of his walking forward motion and continued walking forward away from her. After she hit the ground she pulled her gun, while they were walking away from her.
Counterpoints:
It was a three on one situation while she was on the ground. That’s scary shit for anyone.
She didn’t shoot the gun at all, just pulled it to let it be known that the situation has changed and she is afraid enough to use it. She testified she pointed the gun at him briefly, so that is almost as dangerous as actually pulling the trigger.
Yeah, I do feel bad for her, but if a group of people are insulting you from a distance, approaching them is the exact opposite of the right thing to do.
If I’m in the woods and I see a bear that starts huffing at me, approaching it is a really bad move (bears do that to tell you to fuck off).
And turn the situation around:
Some dude is standing outside a country-western bar when 3 black women start calling him a racist redneck. He runs over there to start shit, and they push him to the ground. How angry would we be if he pulled a gun on them in that moment?
Always good to live in a Stand Your Ground state. It’s ridiculous that some states can convict you of felonies for defending your life, just because the judge believed you had the option to run from your attacker. Luckily, that is fewer and fewer states every year.
Edit: From the comments below, sounds like Stand Your Ground isn’t relevant in this situation, as she was not being threatened with death or grievous bodily harm. My comment here should therefore be read as a completely standalone item, and not something that is relevant to this article at all.
Always good to live in a Stand Your Ground state.
Is this policy “Stand Your Ground” or “Gay Panic Defense”? The state claims she was the aggressor because she was heckled while crossing the street. Then the “victim” was allowed to shove her, continue until he was on top of her, and only retreat when he was presented with deadly force. At no point does the DA admit she feared for her life.
If the state rules in favor of Durham, “Stand Your Ground” doesn’t mean shit. It remains within the domain of the prosecutor’s office to choose to prosecute one class of people and abide another, entirely based on their personal prejudices.
You got the order of events wrong. She was heckled, then she crossed the street and approached them. That’s why Stand Your Ground will likely not hold up.
If they had approached her, this would be a different story. But witness statements said she had her hand on her hip like she was ready to draw as she approached.
Plus, she drew the gun as they were leaving. The guy who shoved her was shoving her out of the way as they were walking past. Brandishing a weapon while someone is leaving isn’t standing your ground.
Then she initially said in her report that she pulled a knife, which she didn’t have in her possession when the cops showed up.
This case definitely isn’t cut and dry.
Plus, she drew the gun as they were leaving
She claims she pulled the gun as Durham was standing over her threatening her life.
She really hurt her credibility by lying about pulling a knife instead of a gun.
You can retreat and still defend yourself.
Not in the legal sense those words are used. In a “duty to retreat” state you must attempt to retreat if one is available and reasonable before you can attempt to defend yourself. That means you can’t back pedal and shoot someone.
There’s no duty to retreat in Wyoming. The problem is she approached them after they insulted her, which isn’t protected by Stand Your Ground.
And her version she claims she was trying to understand what they were saying. It’s perfectly reasonable if someone is obviously yelling something towards you and you can’t understand it that you get closer. Closing the distance to talk to someone isn’t being the initial aggressor. If this goes to trial, that will be something for a jury to decide. We don’t really get to do that here.
Her version also claims she pulled a non-existent knife instead of a gun. She hasn’t done her credibility any favors here. Witnesses say she approached with her hand at her hip as if she was ready to draw a gun.
If true, that shows that she felt like she was in danger as she approached. That’s not covered by SYG.
This is by no means a cut and dry case of clear self defense.
Yet here you are trying to argue a cut and dry case the other way. That’s for a jury if it goes to trial.
Where did I argue a cut and dry case? I intentionally used indefinite qualifiers.
She didn’t retreat. She approached the group with her hand on her hip where a gun would be. One guy in the group then shoved her out of the way as they were leaving. Then she pulled the gun
This makes the Stand Your Ground defense shaky. They weren’t an active threat before she intentionally put herself in a situation where they could be.
She should have just kept walking or stated on the other side of the road at least, then pulled the gun if they approached her.









