Requiring a fouled player to take the penalty sounds good, but what about hand balls? Nobody’s been fouled. Maybe whoever kicked it last?
I like the IDFK idea, it converts a lot of “I can’t believe that’s a penalty” situations into something more appropriate.
I don’t think we can move the spot back, it’s too ingrained in tradition. Also you’d have to move it a fair bit for it to make a difference.
Stuttered runs, I think do whatever you want mate, it’s your penalty. Perhaps put a timer on the kick, but for me it’s not a big deal.
There should also be a rule that stopping a clear goal scoring opportunity leads to a penalty, wherever it happened. Guy who springs the offside trap but gets flattened before reaching the box has been robbed.
Perhaps there should be an intermediate penalty such as the MLS penalties. Obvious goal scoring opportunity -> penalty as normal. Someone grazed the ball with his hand while facing away -> MLS penalty.
It’s also constantly primary school level discussion.
“Who is better, Ronaldo or Messi?”
“Can Haaland/Mbappe/Bellingham get better than Messi?”
“Is this guy overrated?”
Planet has 8B people, every single one of them is a football fan or knows a football fan. They aren’t watching Real Madrid or Man City playing each week, many of them are watching a local team nobody’s heard of. Many of them volunteer to hang around some no-name club every week to let the kids have some fun.
But no, we need more and more content about the absolute top.